Showing 1 thru -3 of 3
89
points

Carinae 2004 Prestige Red (Mendoza)

  • Online Exclusive
  1. $26
Here's a fiery, bolstered blend of Malbec, Cabernet and Syrah that burns the nostrils with berry, herb and minty oak aromas. The palate gets some major points for its sweet, pure black-fruit flavors but there always seems to be some protruding alcohol that makes you question the label's stated 14%. One one hand it's handsome and just right; on the other it seems…  — M.S.  (2/1/2007)
82
points

Carinae 2004 Reserva Malbec (Mendoza)

  1. $15
Best at the beginning, where balsamic notes blend with earth and leather to create a dark, brooding nose. The palate, however, is dull and reduced; it’s like a bite of devil’s food cake: one bite is enough. Seems like the grapes were picked too late; it’s stewy.  — M.S.  (11/1/2006)
81
points

Carinae 2004 Malbec (Mendoza)

  1. $11
Green and raisiny at the same time, which isn’t a good combination. The wine seems ultra ripe and lacking in red fruit, acids and other balancing elements. Harvested too late? Regardless, it isn’t working.  — M.S.  (11/1/2006)
Showing 1 thru -3 of 3
Facebook Activity
Twitter Activity