91-93 This is deceptively soft, with its tannins full of sweetness and acidity. Behind the opulent façade, the power and dry character are very evident.
— R.V.
(6/25/2011)
91–93. Barrel sample. Showing both a firm tannic structure and jammy black fruits, this is a finely ripe and full wine. It has spice, sweet fruits and a solid tannic core. A wine that is likely to age well.
— R.V.
(4/11/2013)
90-92. Barrel sample. Dense and concentrated; the tannins are a worthy partner to the firm flavors of black plum skin. This wine is solid and chunky, with the year's crisp fruit showing through.
— R.V.
(5/11/2012)
89-91 Barrel sample. Tight tannins, a firm, solid Saint-Estèphe. There are black plum skins, dense fruit, and dark tannins which run right across the wine.
— R.V.
(12/31/2009)