95
points
Elderton 2004 Command Shiraz (Barossa)
-
$83
The current release, 2003, is an excellent wine, but this vintage kicks it up a notch. It’s brighter, fresher and more vibrant than its amply endowed precursor, bursting with peppery raspberries. Creamy and rich, yet wonderfully balanced, and while you could drink it now, it will also cellar well for 10-plus years.
— J.C.
(11/1/2007)
94
points
Schild Estate 2004 Ben Schild Reserve Shiraz (Barossa)
-
$48
This is a big, lush, lavishly oaked wine that nonetheless pulls it all together with balance and elegance. Inky black in color, it leads with a blast of toasty, mentholated oak on the nose, backed by waves of blueberries and mint. Then the flavors call to mind dark chocolate and coconut, accented by almonds and the recurring blueberries. It’s creamy-textured and…
— J.C.
(12/15/2006)
93
points
Gibson's BarossaVale 2005 Australian Old Vine Collection Shiraz (Barossa)
-
$105
Incredibly perfumed, with peppery spice, vanilla, anise and blackberries all forming a wonderful whirlwind of aromas. Yet despite the complexity and obvious concentration, it’s not heavy at all, delivering masses of flavor without excessive weight or obtrusive tannin. Mouthfeel is slightly creamy, the finish is long and spicy; in short, it’s the complete package…
— J.C.
(11/1/2007)