91
points
Montes 2005 Alpha M Red (Apalta)
-
$82
Who said Chile doesn’t make cellar-worthy reds? This vintage of Montes Alpha M is well-oaked, strapped and structured. Early attackers will find coconut, mocha and chocolate running the show, but if you hold the wine for another two to five years, it will likely settle, balance out and become an excellent model for what is high-end Chilean Cabernet Sauvignon (with…
— M.S.
(5/1/2008)
91
points
Santa Rita 2005 Pehuén Carmenère (Apalta)
-
$70
In just its second vintage, this high-end Carmenère is worthy of praise. The bouquet is well-built on aromas of mint, chocolate and herb-infused black fruit, and the palate feel is woven from fine tannins, generous extraction and good acids. Flavors of lush plum, berry, vanilla, spice and coffee make for serious drinking and pondering. Best now through 2010. Only…
— M.S.
(9/1/2009)
90
points
Montes 2005 Folly Syrah (Apalta)
-
$82
Minty, creamy and as oaky as can be. Coconut, sawdust, carob and other barrel-based aromas steal the nose, with secondary black fruit and thick tannins composing the palate. This is a ripped, high-alcohol, almost soupy Syrah that in some people’s eye may seem overdone and too woody. But the fruit is of unquestionable high quality, and if you give it time to air out…
— M.S.
(5/1/2008)