89
points
Castillo Viejo 2002 El Preciado Premier Gran Reserva Red (San Jose)
-
$60
While this ranks as one of the best Uruguayan reds we've come across, it's not a slam dunk. First off, there's the price; $60 is a lot to spend for any wine, let alone one from the frontier. But getting past that there's pretty fruit, purity, texture and balance to this prestige-aimed effort. And it finishes with alluring tobacco and earth notes. The blend is Cab…
— M.S.
(6/8/2010)
89
points
Bouza 2004 Special Barrel Tannat (Uruguay)
-
$50
They call it Special Barrel, and one sniff tells you that this is a Tannat raised in pricey French oak barrels. And that’s not a criticism; the wine is toasty, with alluring charcoal and smoke aromas. The palate is up to it as well, as it exhibits bright, elevated dark-fruit flavors. Nicely balanced for the most part, with plenty of cassis, berry and plum character.
— M.S.
(11/1/2006)
87
points
Castillo Viejo 2005 El Preciado Gran Reserva Red (San Jose)
-
$50
Baked, sweet, heavy aromas turn earthy with time. There’s a lot of size and weight to the palate, but it stays lively and shows balance. Toast, blackberry, coffee and spice flavors lead to a dry, tannic finish. Flavorful but not what you’d call elegant. Cab Franc, Tannat, Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon.
— M.S.
(12/15/2011)