89
points
Patz & Hall 2009 Hyde Vineyard Pinot Noir (Carneros)
-
$65
A big Pinot Noir, rich and extracted, and lacking delicacy at this time. It’s as full-bodied as a Rhône blend, with jammy cherry, blueberry and spice flavors, enriched by lots of sweet new oak. Delicious, yes, if you care to drink it now. Try cellaring for four or five years to see if it mellows.
— S.H.
(3/1/2012)
87
points
Carr 2007 Three Vineyards Pinot Noir (Sta. Rita Hills)
-
$40
Here’s a dark, rich, somewhat heavy Pinot Noir, of the type sometimes referred to as Rhône-like. It lacks vibrancy, but is very rich in red cherry pie filling, cola, oatmeal cookie, cocoa, vanilla and smoky meringue flavors. Drink now.
— S.H.
(8/1/2009)
91
points
Lenné Estate 2006 Pinot Noir (Yamhill-Carlton District)
-
$45
A rich, lush, well-structured and seamless Pinot Noir, the 2006 Lenné brings brambly cherry fruit with streaks of herb, leaf and spice. The alcohol, pushing close to 15%, shows up as a slight burn in the finish, but the wine brings in interesting notes of mint and chervil in the aromatic finish.
— P.G.
(10/1/2008)
89
points
Soléna 2005 Guadalupe Pinot Noir (Yamhill-Carlton District)
-
$35
This popular vineyard, now almost 20 years old, yields a brambly Pinot Noir which might pass for a Sonoma Coast bottling. More elegant, almost steely, than many of the other Soléna vineyard designates, this offers cooler fruit flavors of rhubarb and wild strawberry, along with anise and dried herb.
— P.G.
(7/1/2008)
86
points
Cartlidge & Browne 2005 Pinot Noir (California)
-
$13
Wine lovers who want to figure Pinot out but are on a limited budget would do well to buy this one. It’s properly dry and silky, with cherry, strawberry, cola, tea and cinnamon clove flavors. The wine, made from components from Mendocino to Santa Barbara, is a testament to the fine art of blending.
— S.H.
(12/31/2006)