Top 50 Spirits 2011

Arguably, 2011 was the year of whiskey. Never before have so many and so varied new expressions of the spirit come to the U.S. market—smoky and smooth, blended and single malt, Bourbon and Scotch and something else altogether. So if this year’s Top 50 seems heavily weighted toward the whiskey category, it’s with good reason. But whiskey may need to watch its back as 2012 rounds the corner, because so many other spirit categories have wonderful offerings too: aged rums, Tequilas and bright young upstart mezcals, plus a growing range of liqueurs, from stalwarts to fresh new flavors, and nearly-forgotten products that importers are reintroducing. Any one of these could change the spirits landscape in the year ahead.

The 50 spirits on the following pages represent the best of what we tasted in 2011 exclusively, so if a particular spirit category is not represented, it may be due to few, or relatively less notable, submissions. But it’s a pleasure to introduce what we have—a list of 50 stellar spirits.

As always, Wine Enthusiast's Top 50 Spirits is split into categories rather than ranked 1-50. The list represents the best of what we tasted in 2011 exclusively, so if a particular spirit category is not represented, it may be because of few, or relatively less notable, submissions.

96
points

Gentleman Jack Rare Tennessee Whiskey

  1. $30
Top 50 Spirits 2011
This honey-colored whiskey is mellow, smooth, mouthwatering and delicious. Rich and pretty caramel and citrus aromas precede complex flavors of leather, tobacco, vanilla and cocoa. Its long finish displays lots of caramel, spicy cinnamon and ginger. Pair with a cigar.  — K.N.  (3/1/2011)
93
points

Charbay Hop-Flavored Whiskey

  1. $325
Top 50 Spirits 2011
This whiskey reads like a cross between Bourbon and a fine Cognac, delivering rich aromas of caramel, espresso and crème brûlée. Although initially brisk and spicy, the flavor fades to a long burnt-toffee finish and bracing bite. Feels warm and soft on the tongue.  — K.N.  (3/1/2011)
93
points

Canadian Club Sherry Cask Whisky

  1. $26
Top 50 Spirits 2011
Aged eight years, then finished in Spanish Sherry casks. The final product is mellow, silky and refined. While the Sherry influence isn’t overt, the extra cask aging shows in the deep nut-brown color and warm flavors of dark chocolate, Guinness stout and hazelnuts, which fade into a long, intriguing finish. Pair with a sweet and sticky dessert.  — K.N.  (3/1/2011)
95
points

Slieve Foy 8 year old Irish Single Malt Whiskey

  1. $45
Top 50 Spirits 2011
This was a pleasant surprise: soft, fresh, delicate and lovely. It has a light straw color and is perfumed with pineapples and tropical fruit. The slightly fruity flavor finishes with a wispy smokiness, and lingers on.  — K.N.  (3/1/2011)
93
points

John L. Sullivan Irish Whiskey

  1. $24
Top 50 Spirits 2011
This Bourbon-barrel-finished whiskey is a treat, with a light amber color, caramel and orange peel aroma, and a lingering caramel and spice finish. Soft, smooth and full-bodied.  — K.N.  (3/1/2011)
92
points

Hibiki Aged 12 Years Whisky

  1. $65
Top 50 Spirits 2011
With a little water, this golden blended whisky opens up to delicate, nuanced honey and floral aromas and flavors. Finishes smoky, dry and brisk.  — K.N.  (3/1/2011)
Facebook Activity
Twitter Activity