Top 50 Spirits 2011

Arguably, 2011 was the year of whiskey. Never before have so many and so varied new expressions of the spirit come to the U.S. market—smoky and smooth, blended and single malt, Bourbon and Scotch and something else altogether. So if this year’s Top 50 seems heavily weighted toward the whiskey category, it’s with good reason. But whiskey may need to watch its back as 2012 rounds the corner, because so many other spirit categories have wonderful offerings too: aged rums, Tequilas and bright young upstart mezcals, plus a growing range of liqueurs, from stalwarts to fresh new flavors, and nearly-forgotten products that importers are reintroducing. Any one of these could change the spirits landscape in the year ahead.

The 50 spirits on the following pages represent the best of what we tasted in 2011 exclusively, so if a particular spirit category is not represented, it may be due to few, or relatively less notable, submissions. But it’s a pleasure to introduce what we have—a list of 50 stellar spirits.

As always, Wine Enthusiast's Top 50 Spirits is split into categories rather than ranked 1-50. The list represents the best of what we tasted in 2011 exclusively, so if a particular spirit category is not represented, it may be because of few, or relatively less notable, submissions.

96
points

The Dalmore Cigar Malt Reserve

  1. $125
Top 50 Spirits 2011
Honey-amber color and a big butterscotch aroma. Intriguingly dry and earthy, with leather, tobacco, dark chocolate and clove flavors, which accelerate with repeated sips and linger on. Add ice if you must, but avoid watering down this delicious after-dinner treat, which would be even better accompanied by a well-selected dark chocolate or two.  — K.N.  (12/15/2011)
95
points

Glenmorangie The Nectar D’Or 12 Years Old

  1. $70
Top 50 Spirits 2011
This golden spirit is often flagged by bartenders and sommeliers as a favorite; it’s easy to see why. A decade in Bourbon casks, plus an extra two years in Sauternes barriques yields a fresh honeysuckle and vanilla perfume and a super-smooth spirit with creamy honey and nut flavors, with hints of dark chocolate and cinnamon. Very few spirits have such elegance and…  — K.N.  (12/15/2011)
95
points

Douglas of Drumlanrig: Laphroaig 17 years old

  1. $189
Top 50 Spirits 2011
For those who prefer a peaty Scotch style, this is an excellent, food-friendly example that won’t blow out your palate with smoke. This straw-colored spirit has a pronounced but delicate brininess, which builds gently with repeated sips. Pair this light-bodied spirit with oysters or other shellfish.  — K.N.  (12/15/2011)
94
points

Glen Garioch 1994 Small Batch Release

  1. $120
Top 50 Spirits 2011
This 17-year-old Highland Scotch is well structured and remarkably aromatic. The incredibly rich, buttery vanilla scent all but leaps out of the glass, tempered by fresh apple and floral notes. The flavor is bracing and briny, light-bodied and with just a hint of caramel. Pale straw color.  — K.N.  (12/15/2011)
94
points

The Balvenie 17 Year Old Peated Cask

  1. $130
Top 50 Spirits 2011
The tagline on the label reads “sweet spice and smoke,” and it’s an apt description. This bright amber spirit with golden highlights has a fruity, fresh scent and a light waft of smoke on the palate, finishing with orange peel and caramel. Add water to for a smoother, creamier texture. Just enough smoke and alcohol bite.  — K.N.  (12/15/2011)
93
points

Highland Park Aged 12 Years

  1. $46
Top 50 Spirits 2011
Elegant, light and pretty. This amber spirit has a light, briny vanilla scent and a silky feel. A veil of smoke rises through the Scotch (but fades out fast), leaving behind a sweet nutty, vanilla finish.  — K.N.  (12/15/2011)
Facebook Activity
Twitter Activity