95
points
Madrigal 2005 Barberis Family Vineyard Petite Sirah (Napa Valley)
Editors' Choice Online Exclusive
Price
$50
Fifty bucks for Petite Sirah? You bet. It’s a huge wine, black as midnight, dry and tannic, with amazingly deep, long flavors of currants, Mexican chocolate mole sauce, crême de cassis, sweet old leather, anise, pepper, cinnamon and smoky oak. Has the balanced complexity of a great Napa Cabernet Sauvignon, with Petite Sirah’s classic earthiness and depth. This…
— S.H.
(4/1/2009)
94
points
Envy 2008 Nord Vineyard Petite Sirah (Napa Valley)
Price
$45
Big, rich, thick, showing all the hallmarks of a wine that means business. Very great from a Petite Sirah point of view, massively constructed in blackberries, cherries, blueberries, anise, coffee, cocoa and spices, with firm, rich tannins, and the briary, slightly rustic mouthfeel that characterizes the variety. Really good now, with decanting, and should develop…
— S.H.
(9/1/2011)
94
points
Kent Rasmussen 2007 Esoterica Chavez-Leeds Vineyard Petite Sirah (Rutherford)
Editors' Choice Online Exclusive
Price
$40
Very dry and tannic, as Petite Sirah should be. But unlike many “Pets,” it’s also balanced and elegant. The official alcohol is only 13.5%, yet there’s not a trace of greenness. In fact, the wine, which has plenty of French oak, is quite rich in blackberry and black currant flavors. Really a superb example, a Petite Sirah for Cabernet fans. Should evolve…
— S.H.
(9/1/2010)
94
points
Turley 2003 Hayne Vineyard Petite Sirah (Napa Valley)
Price
$80
What an aroma. So Côte-Rôtie, so powerful and rich, yet so refined. Masses of white pepper, cassis, freshly ground French roast, cocoa, gingersnap cookie, char, vanilla, cinnamon—and that’s just the smell! In the mouth, there’s all that and more. Dry, massive, deep and long. A triumph. 2008–2020.
— S.H.
(12/1/2006)
93
points
C. Beck 2005 Petite Sirah (Napa Valley)
Price
$38
A shade less opulent but finer and more structured than the ’04. The tannins are as fine as in any Napa cult Cab, yet the flavors are exotic, with tiers of black currants, red cherries, licorice, dark chocolate, violets, pepper, leather and Chinese mu shu plum sauce. Drink now with substantial roasts; should age for a decade.
— S.H.
(9/1/2008)
93
points
Bardessono 2006 Petite Sirah (Napa Valley)
Price
$43
This is a very Cabernet-like Petite Sirah. It’s full-bodied, dry and balanced, with moderate alcohol and not a huge amount of over-extracted fruit. Enriched with 50% new oak, it has rich flavors of cassis, cherries, cocoa and pepper, in a fleshy texture. Highly recommended.
— S.H.
(10/1/2008)