91
points
A Donkey and Goat 2007 Fenaughty Vineyard Syrah (El Dorado)
-
$35
An impressive Syrah, not just for its ripeness, but for the structure. Fine, firm tannins and acids, along with well-integrated oak, provide a classic framework to the ripe blackberries, leather and chocolate. Good now, with decanting, but really wants 2–4 years of aging.
— S.H.
(2/1/2010)
87
points
A Donkey and Goat 2004 Vieilles Vignes Syrah (McDowell Valley)
-
$34
This Mendocino region has some very old Syrah vines, and they have produced a dark, soft, lush Syrah, with an earthy component to the blackberry and mocha flavors. It’s pretty tannic, but that softness makes it instantly drinkable, and it’s not likely to improve with age.
— S.H.
(5/1/2006)