90
points
Abelis Carthago 2007 William Selection Crianza Tempranillo (Toro)
-
$27
Big, toasty, spicy and loaded with savory berry aromas, smoke and density. The palate is weighty and saturated, but balanced. Flavorwise, it’s dealing sweet, jammy, slightly roasted black fruit tastes that are followed by a spicy, toasty, coffee-driven finish. Meaty and ripe; drink now through 2013.
— M.S.
(7/1/2011)
88
points
Abelis Carthago 2004 Fighting Bulls Tinta de Toro (Toro)
-
$60
Abelis Carthago’s top wine, Fighting Bulls, is also its toughest to enjoy. There’s overripeness and barnyard on the nose, and thus the prune, black plum and jammy berry flavors that control the palate are not surprising. Big and forceful for sure, but also choppy and incongruent across the palate.
— M.S.
(4/1/2008)