93
points
Arger-Martucci 2005 Odyssey Red (Atlas Peak)
-
$50
This is a big, powerful and still young Cabernet blend that’s not ready to drink yet. The massive blackberry, black currant, violet and dark chocolate flavors haven’t meshed with the smoky oak, while a cut of fruity acidity makes for a tart mouthfeel. But it should easily negotiate the years. Better after 2011, and should blossom afterwards.
— S.H.
(12/31/2009)
89
points
Arger-Martucci 2003 Pinot Noir (Carneros)
-
$30
There’s something Burgundian about this Pinot. You’ll find an earthy, sautéed mushroom, almost barnyardy quality to the cherry and cola fruit. The oak is strong, lending spices and wood tannins. Even at four-plus years, the wine is a little awkward on opening. Decant, or hold through 2008.
— S.H.
(3/1/2008)
89
points
Arger-Martucci 2004 Syrah (Napa Valley)
-
$30
Tannic and unyielding now, this Syrah is full-bodied and soft, with cola, blackberry tea, bitter chocolate and leather flavors. It’s a young, fresh, very dry wine, with a complex, chewy mouthfeel. The tannins suggest upscale red meats and fine cheeses.
— S.H.
(10/1/2006)