95
points
Barossa Valley Estate 1998 E&E Black Pepper Shiraz (Barossa Valley)
-
$80
Truly splendid, opulent berry, spice, caramel and cocoa aromas and flavors mark our top-rated Aussie Shiraz. The rich, velvety palate pours on layer after layer of flavor and texture, showing beautiful integration and near perfect fruit-acid-tannin balance. Finishes long with dense fruit and even tannins, closing with commensurate style. So drinkable now, but will…
— W.E.
(11/1/2001)
94
points
Barossa Valley Estate 1996 E&E Black Pepper Shiraz (Barossa Valley)
Offers a compelling, unusual mix of Christmas spice, Worcestershire sauce, tawny Port, meat and pepper on the nose. Bright acids and chewy tannins characterize the palate, which offers juicy, meaty flavors but not the full-throttle, over-the-top lushness that characterizes some other vintages. Finishes long, with dust and bacon notes. Drink now–2010.
— W.E.
(3/1/2005)
93
points
Barossa Valley Estate 1998 E&E Black Pepper Shiraz (Barossa Valley)
From a terrific vintage, and still going strong. Smells great—like beef and leather, with black fruit underneath. In the mouth, it’s structured and bright, its pure berry fruit operating in easy harmony with accents of pencil eraser and caramel. Finishes long. Drinking well now, but could easily go through 2015 or so.
— W.E.
(3/1/2005)
92
points
Barossa Valley Estate 1994 E&E Black Pepper Shiraz (Barossa Valley)
What we liked best about this vintage is its lush, velvety grip on the midpalate—its texture is just A-1. The panel had differing ideas about whether it should be drunk now or held even longer to see how its blackberry and dried spice flavors develop. In any case, it’s drinking beautifully now. Smells of black pepper, smoke, toasted nuts, and all things smoldering…
— W.E.
(3/1/2005)