94
points
Dutschke 2005 Oscar Semmler Single Vineyard Reserve Shiraz (Barossa Valley)
-
$60
This is terrifically lush and easy to drink now, but don’t be fooled into thinking this won’t age—there’s plenty of structure lurking underneath the layers of blackberry and blueberry fruit and veneer of toasty, vanilla-marked oak. Plus, there’s spicy complexity as well, lending savory, meaty notes to the compelling mix. Drink now–2020.
— J.C.
(11/1/2007)
93
points
Dutschke 2006 Oscar Semmler Single Vineyard Reserve Shiraz (Barossa Valley)
-
$60
Takes ripeness to its uppermost limits without going over the top, with aromas of leather and chocolate leading into flavors of chocolate, dried fruit and coffee. It’s full bodied, concentrated and creamy in texture, with a long, lush finish. Despite the ripeness and richness, it’s under 15% alcohol. Drink now-2020.
— J.C.
(3/1/2010)
93
points
Dutschke 2005 St. Jakobi Single Vineyard Shiraz (Barossa Valley)
-
$40
Compared to Dutschke’s top-of-line Oscar Semmler Reserve, this is a softer, almost pillowy style of Shiraz, luxurious in the way the tannins caress the palate. Complex flavors of cola, mint, pepper, blackberries, vanilla and dried spices finish long, showing a hint of warmth but also lingering fruit and licorice flavors. Drink now–2015.
— J.C.
(11/1/2007)