93
points
Edmunds St John 1997 Fenaughty Vineyard Syrah (El Dorado County)
-
$30
Almost black in color, with amazing aromas of pepper, plum, blackberry, earth, dark chocolate and oak. So much depth and complexity, it wows you. Very tannic now, but with all this going for it, it should be spectacular in a few years.
— S.H.
(6/1/1999)
91
points
Edmunds St John 1996 Durell Vineyard Syrah (Sonoma Valley)
-
$25
Classic Rhône aromas of pepper, leather, smoke, animal, spice, vanilla and berry. Ripe and complex, and not as tannic as the Fenaughty Syrah, but very sweet and extracted fruit. You could drink it now but it should improve.
— S.H.
(6/1/1999)