92
points
El Molino 2004 Chardonnay (Rutherford)
-
$42
Napa Cabs can suffer from a soft earthiness, but El Molino has succeeded in producing a wine of real substance and style. It shows fine pear, apple and nut bread flavors, along with a figgy, raisiny quality, and has good enough acidity for balance. The finish is very dry. This complex wine should age well over the next five years.
— S.H.
(6/1/2006)
90
points
El Molino 1999 Chardonnay (Rutherford)
-
$40
The graceful, subtle nose of pears, apples and hazelnuts don’t prepare you for the richness of this old-guard Napa producer’s 1999 offering. A full and intense palate of toast, honey, spice and pineapple comes on strong. The flavors are supported by bright acidity, and they linger on the long and lively finish.
— W.E.
(7/1/2001)
89
points
El Molino 2005 Pinot Noir (Rutherford)
-
$55
El Molino continues to make Pinot Noir, not Cabernet, from Rutherford, and it’s because their fans recognize a nice wine. Pale in color and light-bodied as in previous vintages, it’s nonetheless a delicious red, rich in cherry pie, cotton candy, cola, orange tea, vanilla cinnamon and pepper spice flavors. The mouthfeel is as light and silky as a cloud.
— S.H.
(12/1/2008)
87
points
El Molino 1999 Pinot Noir (Napa Valley)
-
$51
Pepper and plum, slightly candied raspberry fruit plus a full, velour-like texture show in this ripe Napa offering, but panelists still had mixed opinions. To some, the berry and vanilla flavors and rich feel had great appeal, while othersound the wine cedary and a bit hot, with wood and alcohol to spare.
— W.E.
(10/1/2002)