91
points
Garretson 2001 “The Aisling” Syrah (Paso Robles)
-
$30
A distinctive, eccentric Syrah, due mainly to the aromatics, which are unusually powerful in dried leather, porcini mushroom and cocoa. You’ll find blackberries and black cherries in the mouth, and oak. Bottom line is a soft, dry wine, balanced and complex, showing real terroir.
— S.H.
(12/31/2004)
91
points
Garretson 1999 Alban Vineyard - The Finné Syrah (Edna Valley)
-
$60
Mat Garretson, formerly at Eberle and Wild Horse, has been a leader in the California Rhône movement for years, so it is no surprise that his top Syrah is an excellent wine, blending thick blackberry-jam aromas and flavors with hickory smoke and folding in some earth, coffee and cedar.
— W.E.
(11/1/2001)
90
points
Garretson 2001 Rozet Vineyard “The Lusacain” Syrah (Paso Robles)
-
$45
Almost super ripe, displaying intense, soft cherry, cassis, coffee and smoked meat flavors, with a touch of oak. Saved from flatness by a dusty jacket of tannins. An interesting wine, good by itself, better with the right fare. Grilled lamb, filet mignon, with some sweetness in the sauce or topping.
— S.H.
(12/31/2004)