95
points
J.L. Chave 1998 Syrah (Hermitage)
-
$100
Opens with a vibrant berry, chocolate, Asian-spice, rosemary, olive and bacon-fat nose so good you linger before tasting. Sour cherry, licorice, brush, leather and a meaty note show on the palate. The wine is lean yet velvety, with powerful, deep structure. It closes with full, ripe tannins, notes of black tea and pepper. Cellar this keeper until 2004, drink…
— W.E.
(11/1/2001)
94
points
J.L. Chave 1996 Red (Hermitage)
-
$65
In 1996 this extraordinary producer of Hermitage made a wine for the long haul. At release, it displayed superb fruit, bacon, anise, and tobacco flavors, all enveloped by huge tannins. Now it is going through a dumb stage, though the structure is there. Give it ten or 15 years and it will become something extraordinary.
— W.E.
(11/15/1999)
91
points
J.L. Chave 2003 Offerus Syrah (Saint-Joseph)
-
$23
Although Chave’s négociant bottling labeled Offerus can be a bit underfruited in some years, in the superripe 2003 vintage that’s not an issue. It’s rich, full and velvety, with blueberry fruit accented by peppery spice, meaty, black olive notes and a touch of espresso. Delicious now, but should have stuffing to last through 2015.
— J.C.
(11/15/2006)