95
points
JLC 2004 Spofford Station Estate Syrah (Walla Walla Valley (WA))
-
$32
This is a gorgeous mix of Rhône-like herbs, spices, earthy funk and tight, tart fruit. It plays out beautifully on the palate, blended seamlessly and expanding into a luscious rainbow of fruit and earth and herb. There is nothing heavy or hot here, but the concentration (just under 15% alcohol) is superb.
— P.G.
(5/1/2008)
92
points
JLC 2004 Cabernet Sauvignon (Columbia Valley (WA))
-
$25
This is exceptionally concentrated, a dense collage of berry and cassis fruits, sap and spice, from excellent Lewis vineyard fruit. There’s plenty of acid, giving it unusual focus; the wine is detailed and sharp, and it drills down through its flavors rather than spreading them out broadly. Some dill notes arrive in the finish; just a hint that adds some texture…
— P.G.
(5/1/2008)
92
points
JLC 2004 Spofford Station Estate Merlot (Walla Walla Valley (WA))
- Editors' Choice
- Online Exclusive
-
$36
Though not as powerful and concentrated as the Spofford Station Syrah, this wine displays the same distinctive, complex flavor palette—a mix of earth, herb, compost, fungus, smoke, rock and, oh yeah, baby, oodles of fruit. This sort of flavor profile is similar to the biodynamic wines of Cayuse, but at half the cost.
— P.G.
(8/1/2008)
90
points
JLC 2004 Spofford Station Estate Cabernet Sauvignon (Walla Walla Valley (WA))
-
$36
A good wine in a difficult year, this estate-grown Cabernet does not lean heavily on new oak, nor does it need to. Blackberry, cassis and earth form the solid core, and there are substantial, natural-tasting acids providing support. The neutral barrels were half American and half French, but it’s the fruit and vineyard that are most on display.
— P.G.
(3/1/2009)
89
points
JLC 2005 Spofford Station Estate Syrah (Walla Walla Valley (WA))
-
$32
There’s good funk and bad funk; this is right on the border. Scents of earth and compost, gamy meat and bitter greens run amok on the palate, almost concealing the fruit. The interplay of flavors and the overall complexity and length mark this as a Spofford Station Syrah, but just as it should be knitting together, it falls apart, leaving a trail of black olives in…
— P.G.
(8/1/2009)