94
points
Matthews 2002 Red (Columbia Valley (WA))
-
$50
This young, dense, saturated, complex and extremely tight wine is sappy and packed with myriad berries and red/blue fruits. It is wrapped in stiff, hard, thick, dark tannins that add tight layers of moist earth, black tea, roots and bitter chocolate. This baby needs time.
— P.G.
(12/15/2005)
94
points
Matthews 2004 Hedges Vineyard Syrah (Red Mountain)
-
$50
A step beyond the immense 2003, this actually supercedes the sheer massive power of that wine with a sleeker, more elegant structure. Classy, bright, lifted scents lead into a peppery, red-fruited Syrah annotated with citrus oil. Tart, young, clean and delineated, it is Matt Loso’s immaculate, concise winemaking at its best. This can go a long way; it continues to…
— P.G.
(11/15/2006)
93
points
Matthews 2003 Red (Columbia Valley (WA))
-
$60
This has rich tannins, dense fruit and overall deep flavors. This is a dark wine, just this side of brooding, with ripe blueberry and cherry fruit, softly chalky tannins, whiffs of smoke and splashes of pepper. The dark fruit flavors are bold and seamless, melded with smoke and chocolate, dotted with ground espresso, and finished with a nice lift. This probably…
— P.G.
(12/1/2007)
93
points
Matthews 2001 Elerding Vineyard Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon (Yakima Valley)
-
$60
This single-vineyard effort, the top bottle from Matthews, is a comet of a Cab that streaks across the palate with crisp, tart, tightly focused berry fruits. It leaves behind a tail that broadens into a pretty rainbow of flavors—black cherry, mineral, black tea—and keeps its concentration through a long, resonant finish.
— P.G.
(11/15/2004)
91
points
Matthews 2004 Claret Red (Columbia Valley (WA))
-
$30
Because he blends shortly after fermentation, Matt Loso’s wines attain a seamless complexity early on; it’s a hallmark of the winery. This beautifully crafted Claret has no rough edges; in fact, no edges at all. It is a supple, elegant wine, loaded with fruit flavors that run from berry to cherry to plum, while the oak gently adds spice and toast.
— P.G.
(12/1/2007)
90
points
Matthews 2004 Klipsun Sauvignon Blanc (Red Mountain)
-
$18
Winemaker Matt Loso dropped Semillon from the blend a few years ago, then tried fermenting in all stainless, moved to barrels in 2005 and will jump to concrete in 2006. The 2004 Klipsun is yeasty, bone dry and richly textured. The young, beery yeast flavors are augmented with light, fresh herbs and hints of citrus zest and honey. Lingering, lovely textures.
— P.G.
(12/15/2005)