90
points
McDowell 1999 Reserve - McDowell Valley Syrah (Mendocino)
-
$24
Raspberry aromas and flavors dominate the McDowell—in the bouquet, they’re bolstered by blueberry and linseed aromas, and, on the palate, chocolate, earth and walnut flavors. Medium-weight and a little tart on the palate and on the long, toasty finish. Top Value.
— W.E.
(11/1/2001)
89
points
McDowell 1997 Mendocino Estate Syrah (Mendocino)
-
$22
An oakier, more intense style than the regular Syrah. Shows berry, plum, violet, earth, oak and peppery notes, but is closed and tannic in the mouth. But the richness and concentration are there. Give it three or four years, then try again.
— S.H.
(6/1/1999)