88
points
McIlroy 1998 Porter-Bass Vineyard Zinfandel (Russian River Valley)
-
$18
Very good, not great Zinfandel. Makes all the right moves, with spicy, peppery berry fruit, dry, thick tannins, good acidity and a nice roundness from oak that does not overpower. Offers plenty of pleasure, and finishes with a bite of acidity. Could use more depth, though.
— S.H.
(11/1/2002)
87
points
McIlroy 1999 Aquarius Ranch Merlot (Russian River Valley)
-
$21
A wine that elicits mixed feelings. On the plus side, subtle fruit and oak, with a rich earthiness and sleek tannins. Does a good job of keeping Merlot fat and plump, while maintaining an herbal character. On the other hand, there’s pronounced acidity and a sharpness that shows up on the finish. Doesn’t seem likely to age well, but you never know. —S.H.
— S.H.
(9/1/2002)
83
points
McIlroy 1999 Salzgeber Vineyard Cabernet Franc (Russian River Valley)
-
$24
Rare are the places that Cabernet Franc produces a distinctive wine. In fact, no savory Russian River Valley examples come to mind. This wine suggests the difficulties. Very tannic and raw, highly acidic, and although it’s dark in color, lacking fruity extract. Nor is it a wine to age. It’s barren now, and not going anywhere. —S.H.
— S.H.
(9/1/2002)