89
points
Penny's Hill 1999 Shiraz (McLaren Vale)
-
$33
Blackberry, cream and a doughy note on the nose open to attractive cherry-licorice and coffee flavors. This is medium-weight and complex, with olive, caramel, mineral and earth notes, though not particularly deep. Closes with a tangy, peppery finish. A split-decision for our panel, but enjoyed by most tasters.
— W.E.
(11/1/2001)