86
points
Potel-Aviron 2000 Côte du Py Vieilles Vignes Gamay (Morgon)
-
$17
A dark and brooding nose shows depth, and in the mouth this has a smooth, appealing mouthfeel, a soft creaminess. There’s also tart, tangy Gamay fruit and ample oak. This is svelte and appealing, with a wood-and-slightly-sour-fruit quality reminiscent of some modern Barberas. Perhaps an odd reference for Beaujolais, but that where it’s at. Different stuff, with a…
— W.E.
(11/15/2002)
85
points
Potel-Aviron 2000 Vielles Vignes Gamay (Moulin-à-Vent)
-
$17
A very appealing dark berry, violet and game nose opens this dense, smooth wine. But the wood sits heavily on the ripe, plush (for Gamay) fruit. This has fine texture and good length, but the palate never quite shows what the aromas promise at the very strong start. If this opens with another year or two of aging, it has the potential to shine.
— M.M.
(11/15/2002)