93
points
Scherrer 2002 Fort Ross Vineyard Pinot Noir (Sonoma Coast)
-
$38
Tasted alongside Scherrer’s regular Sonoma Coast Pinot, this one’s considerably richer and crisper. It’s tart in fresh young acids, with marvelously complex waves of cherries, pomegranates, cola, sweet rhubarb, espresso and pepper, in a silky-smooth texture. Offers compellingly good drinking.
— S.H.
(11/15/2005)
93
points
Scherrer 2002 Laguna Pinot Noir (Russian River Valley)
-
$35
I don’t know why Scherrer’s Laguna bottling costs the same as their regular Russian River Pinot, because it’s a better wine. Firmly structured in acids and tannins, it shows waves of cherries, black raspberries, cola, sweet leather, rhubarb and spices that are endlessly complex and rewarding.
— S.H.
(11/15/2005)
92
points
Scherrer 1999 Old Mature Vines Zinfandel (Alexander Valley)
-
$28
Rich, plush and loaded with blackberry, cassis, raspberry, tar and chocolate flavors. Tangy acidity and firm, ripe tannins carry the wine neatly along the palate in an elegant blend that’s showing beautifully now and should age nicely, too.
— J.M.
(3/1/2002)
91
points
Scherrer 2001 Scherrer Old & Mature Vines Zinfandel (Alexander Valley)
-
$28
Fairly densely structured, with lots of toasty oak up front. Black cherry, blackberry, cassis, plum, cedar, spice, coffee and chocolate are well integrated into a complex whole.
— W.E.
(11/1/2003)