92
points
Simon Hackett 1998 Anthony's Reserve Shiraz (McLaren Vale)
-
$38
The fruit aromas are pretty: plums and black cherries. Add fine oak aromas of smoke, cocoa, vanilla, toast and menthol, and this has all the ingredients to please. The acidity is firm, preventing the wine from ever seeming flabby or over the top and giving strength to the long spicy finish.
— W.E.
(6/1/2001)
91
points
Simon Hackett 1999 Chardonnay (Barossa Valley)
-
$15
Ripe and pungent, this opens with a blast of oak-influenced melon and peach aromas, mixed with smoke, spices, and buttered toast. It’s very rich and forward in the mouth, with tropical fruit flavors, some sweetness, and a thick, custardy texture. Of interest are the acids, which are very high and penetrating. Best Buy.
— S.H.
(6/1/2001)
90
points
Simon Hackett 2005 Old Vine Grenache (McLaren Vale)
-
$15
A top-notch offering for current consumption, this wine boasts a complex bouquet of black cherries, cinnamon, clove, coffee, vanilla, herbal notes and hints of green peppercorns—it’s a wine you can sit and sniff almost endlessly. The flavors are more straightforward—black cherry and spice—while the texture is delicate, almost soft. Drink now.
— J.C.
(6/1/2007)
90
points
Simon Hackett 1999 Cabernet Sauvignon (McLaren Vale)
-
$18
The aromas alone are worth the price: black currants and plums, smoke and anise, vanilla and cocoa, and something herbaceous, like tapenade. There are also leathery nuances that give it an almost gamy character. Some mint flavors on the finish, with firm tannins that should allow this wine to age well.
— W.E.
(6/1/2001)