97
points
Staglin 2002 Cabernet Sauvignon (Rutherford)
-
$125
Starts with an extraordinarily complex, refined aroma, detailed and inviting in cassis, tobacco, anise, cocoa and smoky oak. In the mouth, there’s fantastic depth and complexity. The wine is rich, profound, a star even in its Rutherford stable of thoroughbreds. It has enormous power, with finely ground, sweet tannins. Absolutely gorgeous now, with the stuffing and…
— S.H.
(12/31/2005)
96
points
Staglin 2001 Cabernet Sauvignon (Rutherford)
-
$110
One of the best Rutherford wines of the vintage. Dramatically concentrated, everything’s on steroids, but controlled and beautiful. Very ripe and plush, oaky and young, fabulously expressive. Flavors are of black currants, sweet cherries, vanilla, smoke. A perfect expression of youthful brilliance and ageworthiness.
— S.H.
(10/1/2004)
95
points
Staglin 2005 Estate Cabernet Sauvignon (Rutherford)
-
$175
Black in color, glyceriney. Massive, deep, tremendous. Some will find it overpowering in New World extraction, but it’s a real beauty in that style. Explodes in black currants, chocolate and new oak, almost overripe, with suggestions of raisins. Almost dessert-like, but stays dry and elegant. Defines modern Napa Valley cult Cabernet Sauvignon.
— S.H.
(5/1/2009)
94
points
Staglin 2008 Cabernet Sauvignon (Rutherford)
-
$185
The 2008 vintage wasn’t the greatest ever in Napa, and this isn’t the greatest ever Staglin Cabernet. But it is one of the successes of the vintage, showing how a great winery rises over vintage limitations. Feels lush and dramatic in the mouth, with lush, smooth tannins housing classic Cabernet flavors of black currants, plums, green olives and dark chocolate…
— S.H.
(12/31/2011)
94
points
Staglin 2003 Estate Cabernet Sauvignon (Rutherford)
-
$135
What a wonderfully rewarding wine. So delicious and elegant it dazzles, staying firm throughout, and getting even better through the finish. It’s sweetly, opulently ripe, showing a panoply of red and black cherry and mocha flavors wrapped into ripe, dusty, fine tannins. Defines classic Rutherford. Decant if you drink now, or hold through 2020.
— S.H.
(12/31/2006)
92
points
Staglin 2005 Estate Cabernet Sauvignon (Rutherford)
-
$175
This is obviously a beautiful Cabernet Sauvignon. It shows the pedigree and class you expect from a winery of Staglin’s level, enormously rich in black currant, mocha and cedar flavors, with ripe, soft and complex tannins. But the price is challenging. If you choose to buy and cellar, the wine should develop at least for several years.
— S.H.
(12/15/2008)