90
points
The Grapes of Roth 2005 Merlot (Long Island)
-
$50
Big and brooding with richly concentrated black plums and velvety, mouthfilling tannins, Roman Roth’s namesake Merlot is boldly structured, but beautifully nuanced as well, with sprays of violet perfume and just a whiff of wet, earthy forest and dried herb notes. Drink now with a good decant, or hold for another 2–3 years.
— A.I.
(12/31/2011)
86
points
The Grapes of Roth 2001 Merlot (Long Island)
-
$50
Made from one of the best vintages ever on Long Island, and backed by Roman Roth, the winemaking talent behind Wolffer Estate, Shinn Estate and Roanoke. For the most part, it delivers with notes of exotic spice, spearmint and cherry in the nose, and a supple, smoked meat and herbal character whose parts come together with elegance.
— S.K.
(2/1/2007)